Why ‘Princess Mononoke’ Is a Smarter Version of Disney’s ‘Pocahontas’
The movies Princess Mononoke and Disney’s Pocahontas explore similar themes of nature, conflict, and human impact on the environment. However, Princess Mononoke offers a deeper, more complex look at these issues. The 1997 Japanese animated film by Hayao Miyazaki is often considered a more mature and nuanced version of the themes seen in Pocahontas (1995).
‘Princesss Mononoke’ has way more moral complexity than Disney’s ‘Pocahontas’
One of the main similarities between the two films is their portrayal of the relationship between humans and nature. In Pocahontas, the conflict arises when settlers arrive in the New World, threatening the natural balance of the land. Pocahontas, a Native American woman, tries to bridge the gap between her people and the newcomers. While Pocahontas presents a hopeful message about peace, it simplifies the issue by framing it as a fight between good and evil. The film’s resolution feels overly idealistic, with little exploration of the complexities involved in cultural and environmental conflicts.
In contrast, Princess Mononoke takes a much more complicated and realistic approach. The film centers on Ashitaka, a young man who is cursed after killing a boar demon infected by a corrupted iron ball. As he journeys to find a cure, he becomes entangled in a war between human industrialists and the spirits of the forest. Unlike Pocahontas, Mononoke doesn’t provide clear-cut heroes or villains. Instead, it shows that both sides — humans and nature — have valid concerns and motivations. The film acknowledges that humans must use resources to survive, but it also highlights the destructive consequences of industrial progress.
The title character of Disney’s ‘Pocahontas’ has less depth
Another key difference is the way both films depict female protagonists. Pocahontas is portrayed as a peaceful and diplomatic figure who seeks to prevent violence. While this is admirable, it limits her character to a role of mediation without much depth. Princess Mononoke features two powerful female characters — San, the wolf girl, and Lady Eboshi, the leader of the industrial town. Both characters are complex and have their own motivations, making them more multifaceted and compelling than Pocahontas. San, for example, is driven by her desire to protect the forest and its creatures, while Lady Eboshi fights for the progress and survival of her people. These two women challenge the traditional ideas of right and wrong, creating a more thought-provoking story.
Moreover, Princess Mononoke delves into more mature themes, such as the cost of industrialization and the cycle of violence. It doesn’t shy away from showing the harsh realities of conflict. The film presents the idea that peace is difficult to achieve when both sides have legitimate fears and desires. Pocahontas, on the other hand, glosses over the realities of colonization and environmental destruction, offering a more simplified and optimistic view of human relations.
‘Princess Mononoke’ has the better animation even if its from the less famous studio
Finally, the animation style in Princess Mononoke stands out for its breathtaking detail and emotional depth. The world Miyazaki creates is immersive and full of life. The landscapes, creatures, and characters are beautifully designed, making the film feel alive in a way that Pocahontas doesn’t quite match. While Disney’s animation is colorful and expressive, it lacks the same raw energy that Mononoke delivers. Deadline reports Princess Mononoke is back in theaters, so it seems it’s the film with the greater cultural resonance.
